Sicily's Pizza Muldoon is a delightful pizza delivery haven located in Anchorage, Alaska. Customers rave about the sumptuous pizza offerings, which include classics like the Margherita and creatively topped options such as the Popeyes. At $20.99, these pizzas promise a delightful balance of flavors, featuring quality ingredients like mozzarella and fresh spinach. Reviewers like Lydia Seaton describe the establishment as a "hidden gem," praising not only the pizza's taste but also the service, which is noted for its friendliness and efficiency. The ambiance might not impress at first glance, but the food certainly does. Jaeleen Zurfluh shares an enthusiastic experience, highlighting the speed of delivery, noting that an XL pizza vanished before she could enjoy her slice. The online ordering experience, while not flawless for some patrons, ultimately leads to piping hot, fresh meals delivered within minutes, a testament to the restaurant's commitment to quality. Kyle McClanahan enjoyed his All-Meat Large pizza, complimenting the juicy, well-cooked toppings and affordable prices compared to chains like Pizza Hut. Supportive of local business, Keith Graham echoed similar sentiments, affirming both the quality of food and service. Overall, Sicily's Pizza Muldoon is quickly becoming a favorite, offering flavorful pizzas and quick service that leaves customers eager to return.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
No wheelchair-accessible seating
No wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Offers kerbside pickup
Has no-contact delivery
Offers delivery
Offers takeaway
Payments
Accepts debit cards
Credit cards
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Photos
Reviews For Sicily's Pizza Muldoon
lydia Seaton
May 14,2025
This is a hidden gem. Doesn't look like anything good but the pizza was amazing. Tiramisu was VERY good. Friendly service and fast. We will be back
Jaeleen “Sh1tSh0w8.7.3” Zurfluh
Apr 9,2025
Nite time is the right time to order from Muldoon Sicily's. The notes devoured an XL before I could even start eating
James L Boyd Jr
Apr 2,2025
At first I tried using the app from the apple App Store instead of the web but it did not work very well and was very sluggish. I ultimately ended up using the web interface again to order the food. The delivery driver was very nice.
Kyle McClanahan
Mar 25,2025
Great Pizza. Fast Service. Seriously though - From the minute I placed the order up until delivery: 21 minutes. I considered knocking a star for the dough..I have a feeling it has to do with how quickly they cook the pies, and it could have been a tad crispier - but my air fryer can take care of that! :) The pizza itself was delicious. I ordered online for 20% off my order, and I got the All-Meat Large, half Cheese only. The meat is juicy and fresh, and doesn't fall all over the place with each bite you take. Cheese is perfectly cooked, down to the light brown bubbling on the mozzarella. 12/10 will order again. Prices are 1 less per pie VS Pizza Hut. No-Brainer. I doused my pie in Parmesan when I first got it - just FYI for photos lol.
Keith D. Graham
Mar 15,2025
I've ordered delivery twice now. Both times the food arrived piping hot, fresh, and delicious! Online ordering was easy, and the delivery was quick. Very Happy with my experience. Thank you!
Steven Knights
Mar 12,2025
I have been a big fan of Sicily's for a long time. Priced competitively but quality is better than others. Just beware that large pizza is really a medium. If you want a large you need to order an extra large. But the taste is very good !!! Also the lasagna is excellent!
LeeAnna Bohnert
Mar 8,2025
Absolutely delicious!! First time ordering and they hit it outta the park! We got the Alfredo Chicken & All Meat. Called ahead they said 15min was done on time and it was hot, fresh, and sooooo good!!! ...
Chris Hofmann
Feb 28,2025
Their pizza is always amazing and the delivery guys are always nice and friendly. They also have some bomb sandwiches, pasta, chicken, stromboli and fries
Reviews For Sicily's Pizza Muldoon